Why shouldn’t I just take
out a debt consolidation loan or refinance my mortgage?
What is a debtor?
A debtor
is a person who owes someone else money. On the other hand, a creditor is someone
who is owed money.
RETURN TO TOP
What is chapter 7 bankruptcy?
A Chapter
7 bankruptcy is commonly referred to as a “liquidation” or “straight”
bankruptcy. The purpose of chapter 7 bankruptcy is to permit the honest debtor the
ability to discharge most of his obligations to his creditors while retaining sufficient
assets to obtain a “fresh start”. A chapter 7 bankruptcy trustee is
appointed to facilitate both the discharge of the debtor’s debts as well as
the liquidation of all property in excess of the amount deemed necessary under the
Bankruptcy Code for the debtor’s “fresh start”. The property
deemed necessary for the debtor’s “fresh start” is commonly referred
to as “exempt property”. The chapter 7 bankruptcy trustee may only liquidate
the debtor’s non-exempt property. In exchange, the debtor is issued a chapter
7 discharge, freeing him of most (if not all) of his debt. Most debtors, especially
in Texas, own only exempt property resulting in the chapter 7 bankruptcy trustee taking
nothing. Such cases are commonly referred to as “no asset” cases.
RETURN TO TOP
Can anyone file a chapter 7 bankruptcy petition?
Almost any individual, partnership, or corporation can file a chapter 7 bankruptcy petition. The debtor must reside,
have a domicile, a place of business, or property in the United States. This is not, however, to say that every
chapter 7 debtor receives a discharge. Only individuals who have not been granted a discharge within six (6) years
of the filing of a chapter 7 bankruptcy petition are entitled to a discharge. That means partnerships and
corporations never receive a chapter 7 discharge.
RETURN TO TOP
Do I need a lawyer to file a chapter 7 bankruptcy petition?
No, but the process is not as straight forward as you might believe. The wrong answer to a simple question
(i.e. Do I need to list all of my creditors?) can lead to dire results such as the denial of your chapter
7 discharge (often the sole reason for filing). It is highly recommended that
you retain competent legal representation.
RETURN TO TOP
Does my spouse have to file chapter 7 bankruptcy with me?
No. On the other hand, it is often a good idea because of the amount of
joint debts. Moreover, under Texas law, debts incurred during the marriage are deemed to be community debts.
As such, a spouse that does not sign loan documents may be found personally liable for such debts to
the extent there may be recovery had against such spouse’s interest in any non-exempt community
property assets.
Latimer v. City National Bank of Colorado City, 715 S.W.2d 825, 827 (Tex. App.
- Eastland 1986, no writ).
RETURN TO TOP
Do I have to file chapter 7 bankruptcy against ALL of my creditors?
Yes. Whether the debt is owed to a bank, a relative
or a friend, all creditors must be listed. When you sign your chapter 7 bankruptcy
schedules you are stating under penalty of perjury that all of your creditors have
been listed. An intentional failure to list a creditor could result in a denial of
your chapter 7 discharge. On the other hand, mistakes do happen, and in those instances
you will usually be allowed to amend your schedules. Lastly, you should note that
creditors that are not listed in your bankruptcy schedules are not discharged. In
other words, their rights remain unaltered by the chapter 7 bankruptcy.
RETURN TO TOP
What is a chapter 7 discharge?
A chapter 7 discharge is a release of a debtor from personal
liability for certain debts. The discharge is basically a permanent injunction issued against
the debtor’s creditors thereby preventing those creditors from taking any action against
the debtor or the debtor’s property to collect the debts. The discharge also prohibits
creditors from communicating with the debtor regarding the debt, including telephone calls,
letters, and personal contact.
RETURN TO TOP
Can I still pay some creditors after my chapter 7 discharge?
Absolutely.
The Bankruptcy Code contains no prohibition with respect to how you handle your financial
affairs after the chapter 7 discharge. The chapter 7 discharge merely eliminates
the legal obligation to pay the debt. You remain free to spend your money as you
see fit, including the repayment of discharged debts.
RETURN TO TOP
Will I lose all my property if I file a chapter 7 bankruptcy?
Most
debtors who file a chapter 7 bankruptcy petition loose no property. Whether a debtor
will retain all of his or her property depends upon the exemptions code selected as
well as the nature and value of the property owned. Also note that secured creditors
retain their interest in the collateral (house, car etc.) regardless of the chapter
7 bankruptcy. If you wish to retain such items you will be required to continue making
payments to the secured creditor.
RETURN TO TOP
What is an exemption?
An exemption is a state or federal statute which prevents
creditors from taking certain property away from a debtor. The exemptions were created to ensure
that all debtors, despite any monies owed to their creditors, retained certain essential
assets such as a home or a car. Check out the
“exemption” section of this website for more details.
RETURN TO TOP
What property is exempt in a chapter 7 bankruptcy?
Most chapter 7 debtors can exempt everything they own.
Some of the items a chapter 7 debtor may exempt, depending on the exemption statute selected,
include: (1) homestead, (2) vehicles, (3) retirement accounts, (4) pensions, (5)
sports equipment, (6) livestock, and (7) household goods. For a complete list of the
exemptions available to chapter 7 debtors, as well as their respective limitations,
you should view the
“exemption”
section of this website.
RETURN TO TOP
How does the Bankruptcy Court know what I own?
The Bankruptcy Code requires every chapter 7 debtor to complete a set of bankruptcy
schedules. These bankruptcy schedules require the debtor to list everything the
debtor owns or has an interest in. The Bankruptcy Code further provides very harsh
penalties, including the denial of the discharge, for any debtor intentionally omitting
any items. In other words, the debtor, via the chapter 7 bankruptcy schedules, tells
the Bankruptcy Court everything he or she owns.
RETURN TO TOP
Do I have to list everything I own on my chapter 7 bankruptcy schedules?
Yes. If you do not complete the chapter 7 bankruptcy
schedules completely and accurately you will likely not receive a chapter 7 discharge
and will subject yourself to fines and possible imprisonment.
RETURN TO TOP
Will a chapter 7 bankruptcy stop my creditors from calling?
Yes. Section 362(a) of the Bankruptcy Code (the
automatic stay provision) prevents creditors from taking any action to collect
debts. The automatic stay also prevents secured creditors from foreclosing, seizing,
and repossessing their collateral. Once a creditor learns of the chapter 7 bankruptcy
filing, that creditor must immediately stop all collection efforts.
Creditors receive notice of the chapter 7 bankruptcy from the Bankruptcy Court based
upon the information you provided in your bankruptcy schedules. The notification
process will often take one or two weeks. In the interim, when a creditor calls you
should advise them of the bankruptcy filing and provide them with the chapter 7
bankruptcy case number and the date the case was filed. Some cases, however, may
require a more proactive approach. In that situation you or your attorney should
contact the creditor immediately after filing the bankruptcy petition. Examples
of situations requiring immediate notification include: (1) pending litigation,
(2) possible repossession, or (3) possible foreclosure.
RETURN TO TOP
Will a chapter 7 bankruptcy stop a foreclosure or repossession?
Yes. However, a chapter 7 bankruptcy case will
never permanently stop a creditor from foreclosing or repossessing their collateral.
A secured lender, shortly after learning of the chapter 7 bankruptcy case, will
likely file a motion with the Bankruptcy Court for permission to continue the
foreclosure proceedings or repossession (a motion for relief from the automatic
stay). If you wish to retain the collateral you will need to make arrangements
with the secured creditor. Such an arrangement usually requires you to become
current on the obligation in a relatively short time period.
RETURN TO TOP
If my car was repossessed will a chapter 7 bankruptcy help me get my car back?
Yes.
A secured creditor, upon learning of the chapter 7 bankruptcy case, has an affirmative
duty to return the vehicle if the vehicle was not previously sold at auction and the
value of the vehicle to the bankruptcy estate is inconsequential. Moreover, a secured
creditor’s continued retention of a repossessed vehicle after learning of the
chapter 7 bankruptcy case is a violation of the automatic stay.
Nissan Motor Acceptance
Corporation v. Baker, 239 B.R. 484, 487-488 (N.D.Tex 1999).
RETURN TO TOP
If I am in the process of being evicted, will a chapter 7 bankruptcy petition
stop the eviction?
The filing
of a chapter 7 bankruptcy petition to stop an otherwise rightful eviction is not
recommended. The landlord is entitled to possession of his property. Chances are,
within days of learning of the chapter 7 bankruptcy case, the landlord will file a
motion for relief from the automatic stay and request that the matter be heard on
shortened notice. In such a case, you will likely gain little more than an additional
week in the premises. Filing a Chapter 7 bankruptcy case for the sole purpose of
avoiding an eviction constitutes an abuse of the bankruptcy process and may result
in the dismissal of your bankruptcy case.
RETURN TO TOP
If I have been sued by one of my creditors, will a chapter 7 bankruptcy stop
the lawsuit?
A chapter 7 bankruptcy case will stop most civil
lawsuits and IRS proceedings. On the other hand, a chapter 7 bankruptcy case will
not usually stop divorce or criminal proceedings.
RETURN TO TOP
Will a chapter 7 bankruptcy wipe out my second mortgage, my car loan or any other
secured debt?
Generally speaking, no. While there are some
liens that can be removed under chapter 7 of the Bankruptcy Code (i.e. certain
statutory liens, judicial liens and nonpossessory, nonpurchase-money liens) most
secured creditors (typically those with liens upon your home and car) will retain
their lien rights.
RETURN TO TOP
How does my divorce affect my ability or my former spouse’s ability to file
for chapter 7 bankruptcy?
A divorce does not prevent either spouse from filing
bankruptcy. In fact, divorce is one of the primary reasons given by debtors for filing
bankruptcy. If your spouse does elect to file for chapter 7 bankruptcy, you will need
to seriously examine your financial condition. Chances are you and your spouse incurred
numerous joint debts during the course of your marriage. Regardless of the terms of
your divorce papers, you remain liable for those joint debts. As such, since your
spouse’s creditors can no longer pursue him or her because a chapter 7 bankruptcy
case, they will look to you for payment. Moreover, under Texas law, debts incurred
during the marriage are deemed to be community debts. As such, a spouse that does
not sign loan documents may be found personally liable for such debts to the extent
there may be recovery had against such spouse’s interest in any non-exempt community
property assets.
Latimer v. City National Bank of Colorado City, 715 S.W.2d
825, 827 (Tex.App.--Eastland 1986, no writ).
RETURN TO TOP
Can I stop paying alimony after I receive my chapter 7 discharge?
Generally
speaking you must continue making alimony, maintenance and child support payments. As
regards other financial terms of the divorce, the Bankruptcy Code provides that such
payments are not dischargeable if the debtor has the ability to pay them and the
detriment to the non-filing spouse outweighs the benefit of the discharge to the
debtor. Such debts are, however, discharged if the non-filing spouse fails to timely
commence a proceeding requesting that such debts not be discharged. If no such
proceeding is commenced the debtor is not required to continue making payments.
RETURN TO TOP
Can I stop paying on my student loans after I receive my chapter 7 discharge?
Generally speaking,
students loans are not dischargeable under a chapter 7 bankruptcy case. Only if the repayment
of the student loan represents an undue hardship to the debtor and the debtor’s
dependents could a student loan be discharged.
RETURN TO TOP
Will I still have to pay my past due taxes after I receive my chapter 7 discharge?
Maybe, maybe not. Taxes that are more than 3 years
old are dischargeable. However, if you have employees and owe income tax on your
employees’ earnings, those taxes are not dischargeable. Note that taxes not
discharged in a Chapter 7 bankruptcy case can be paid over a period of three to five
years through a chapter 13 plan.
RETURN TO TOP
Will I have to go to bankruptcy court?
After filing
a chapter 7 bankruptcy petition, a meeting of creditors (the 341(a) hearing) is
scheduled before the chapter 7 bankruptcy trustee. The purpose of the meeting is
to meet the debtor and ask questions of him or her. During this meeting creditors
may be present and may ask questions of the debtor, though most do not. Typically,
the meeting lasts less than fifteen minutes and takes place in an office of the federal
courts building or some other meeting room. The meeting does not take place before a
bankruptcy judge and is not located in a Bankruptcy Court. The meetings are generally
scheduled within 30 days of a Chapter 7 bankruptcy filing, and within 45 days of a
Chapter 13 bankruptcy filing. Your attorney will be present at this meeting with you.
Other than the first meeting of creditors, you will likely have no other hearings.
RETURN TO TOP
If I am considering filing for chapter 7 bankruptcy, can I still use my credit cards?
If you are considering filing for chapter 7 bankruptcy
you should immediately stop using your credit cards. The continued use of any credit
cards from this point forward could result in those debts not being discharged.
RETURN TO TOP
Can I pay my bankruptcy lawyer with a credit card or from a cash advance?
No. It would be unethical for any consumer bankruptcy
lawyer to accept payment by credit card knowing that such debt might be discharged
through subterfuge. By agreeing to accept legal fees on a credit card, or indirectly
from a cash advance obtained for paying a bankruptcy attorney, the bankruptcy attorney is participating in a fraud upon the
Bankruptcy Court as well as upon the issuer of the credit card. Such debts are likely
not dischargeable (cash advances and charges for luxury goods exceeding $1,150.00 are
presumed to be nondischargeagble) and any effort to cloke the charge or cash advance
constitutes fraud. This is perhaps best illustrated by the following hypothetical
question: Would a credit card issuer, knowing that the credit card charge proceeds would
be used to pay your bankruptcy attorney, authorize the charge? Of course not! Don’t do it.
RETURN TO TOP
Should I file a chapter 7 bankruptcy petition?
There is no easy answer to this question. Bankruptcy
might be viable if:
• You
or your spouse have been unemployed for the last six months;
• Employment
for you or your spouse has not been steady over the last year and your
credit balances continue to rise;
• If
you are using one credit card to pay down on another credit card (robbing Peter to
pay Paul);
• You
are receiving several collection letters every month;
• You
received a letter from your mortgage company threatening foreclosure;
• Your
vehicle has been repossessed or you fear that it might be repossessed because you are
behind on you monthly payments;
• You
are considering a home equity loan to pay off your credit card debt;
• The
IRS is threatening to garnish your wages or levy your assets;
• You
are considering cashing in part or all of your 401k or IRA to pay your creditors;
• You
have been sued or fear that you might be sued;
• You
have substantial medical bills that you are unable to pay;
If you fall into one of the above listed categories and are contemplating filing for
bankruptcy protection, it is in your best interest to seek advice of a bankruptcy
attorney who can evaluate your individual circumstances to determine which course
of action is best for you.
RETURN TO TOP
Will filing chapter 7 bankruptcy affect my credit?
Yes. All events affecting your credit are recorded.
That includes prompt payments, slow pays, charge-offs, and judgments as well
as a bankruptcy filing. If you are currently contemplating bankruptcy, then it is
likely that your current credit rating has already been negatively impacted.
A chapter 13 bankruptcy discharge will usually
remain on a credit bureau for seven years, whereas a chapter 7 discharge will likely
remain on a credit bureau for ten years. While record of your bankruptcy filing
may be on your credit history for up to 10 years, the reality is that most
people find they are able to completely rebuild their credit within 3 to 5 years. Depending
upon the lender and the reason for incurring new debt, your ability to obtain credit
will likely improve shortly after you receive your chapter 7 discharge. If for no
other reason than the fact that your financial condition has been dramatically improved.
However it is up to you to make sure you rebuild and maintain your credit rating.
If you fail to make steady, regular payments on new or reaffirmed debts you will
likely make a bad situation worse.
RETURN TO TOP
How long will a chapter 7 bankruptcy appear on my credit report?
A chapter 7
bankruptcy discharge will usually remain on your credit report for a period of ten years.
RETURN TO TOP
Will filing chapter 7 bankruptcy affect my job?
No. First, you should note that although bankruptcy
records are of public record, most employers will never learn of the bankruptcy unless
you tell them. Second, if you owe money to your employer you will be required to list
your employer as a creditor on your bankruptcy schedules. In so doing, they will learn
of the bankruptcy filing from the Bankruptcy Court. Lastly, the Bankruptcy Code specifically
prohibits any employer from discriminating against you because you filed a chapter 7
bankruptcy petition.
RETURN TO TOP
Can I keep any credit cards after filing a chapter 7 bankruptcy petition?
Whether or not you will be able to keep any credit
cards after the chapter 7 bankruptcy discharge is a matter between you and your credit
card company. Most credit card companies will not allow you to retain a credit card
if you discharged your debt to them. They will expect you to reaffirm the obligation
before extending any further credit. It is never a good idea to pay for credit. If
you need to use credit after your chapter 7 discharge for work or other reasons, you
should consider a secured credit card.
RETURN TO TOP
Why doesn’t Boyd•Veigel, P.C., advertise to file a chapter
7 bankruptcy for “zero down”?
The advertisements you see respecting “zero
down” bankruptcy are misleading and, in our opinion, unethical. Such adds lead
you to believe you are receiving a benefit not offered by other lawyers. That is
simply not the case. Attorneys advertising “zero down” bankruptcy will
not perform any work until they are paid at least something and will not file your case
until they have been paid their fee in full -- just like all other bankruptcy attorneys.
Realize that almost all attorneys allow you to pay the retainer fee and the Bankruptcy
Court filing fee in installments. The “zero down” bankruptcy advertisement
is little more than a ploy to get you in the door and to sign their retainer agreement.
NOTE: Never retain a lawyer that is willing to file a chapter seven bankruptcy case and collect the fee from you later. That attorney is violating the discharge
provisions of the Bankruptcy Code if any effort is ever made to collect that fee. The
attorney fee was discharged along with all of your other debts. Further, to the
extent the lawyer indicates the fee is for services rendered post-petition, the lawyer
is again violating the tenets of the Bankruptcy Code.
Lamie v. United States Trustee,
540 U.S. 526, 124 S.Ct. 1023, 157 L.Ed.2d 1024 (2004).
RETURN TO TOP
Why shouldn’t I just take out a debt consolidation loan or refinance my mortgage?
This is an excellent question, and one I wish more
people would ask. It is unfortunate, many people who take out debt consolidation loans
to pay off credit card debt often lose their homes to foreclosure. You can never borrow
your way out of debt. Robbing Peter to pay Paul solves nothing.
On the surface, a debt consolidation loan appears
to be a good thing. The debt consolidation loan lowers the amount of payments due
each month. The debt consolidation loan to eliminates large monthly credit card
debt payments at a high rate of interest and replaces them with a substantially
lower monthly payment at a reduced rate of interest. While this looks great, looks
can be deceiving.
First, though the interest rate on a debt consolidation
loan is lower than that on your credit cards, you will pay more in interest and finance
charges over the life of the loan than you might realize because of the extended term.
Second, you have converted an unsecured debt that could be wiped out in bankruptcy
into a secured debt that cannot be wiped out in bankruptcy absent surrendering your
home. Third, if the only way you are able to make the new lower payment on your
debt consolidation loan is to continue using your credit cards (albeit to a lesser
degree than before) you now risk foreclosure.
RETURN TO TOP
Boyd•Veigel, P.C., is proud to represent clients in Plano, Allen, Frisco, McKinney, The Colony, Lewisville, Greenville,
Dallas, Richardson, Arlington, Addison, Mesquite, Rockwall, Carrollton, Sachse, Collin County, Dallas County, Denton County, Hunt County,
and all surrounding areas.